Farmer’s Cheese – Easiest Homemade Cheese Recipe

Cheese – it’s mysterious, delicious and intimidating! But, it doesn’t have to be, intimidating that is: forget the cultures, rennet or dark caves. If you’re a newbie cheese maker, this is a great recipe for getting your feet wet and has lots of room for creativity!

I hadn’t set out to make cheese yesterday morning, but my broken refrigerator decided it would be a good idea to curdle the milk i’d intended to become yogurt. It was still sweet, but heating to yogurt temp was just separating the curds from the whey – which is the first step to making cheese! So, i went for it. Farmer’s cheese is a fairly bland cheese, can get too dry and crumbly and doesn’t melt…. but it can be really delicious especially when you spice it up some! I like to add finely diced garlic, lots of salt and ground hot pepper and rosemary. The combo is delicious! You’ll end up with way more whey than cheese, so if you have hogs or chickens they’ll be your best friends for a day or you can save some as a sipping drink that packs a protein punch. I always freeze a ice cube tray full of it as well to use in lacto fermentation projects. No waste!

Farmer’s Cheese

  • 1 gallon milk – raw or pasteurized, skim or whole. *Whole will make a much tastier cheese.
  • 1/2 cup apple cider vinegar (can also use white or white wine vinegar)
  • T each salt and ground herbs of your choice
  • 2 Large pots
  • Cheesecloth or old bandanna
  • Colander
  • Something heavy

No thermometer required! Heat your milk to a rolling boil. Turn off the heat and add vinegar. The milk should begin separating/curdling right away. You want t0 fully separate the whey from the curds (whey should be yellowish clear, not milky looking). Once separating, pour the whey and curds into your colander lined with cheesecloth over another large pot (you could do this over the sink, but why waste all that useful whey??). Stir in salt and herbs to the curds, then tie up the cheesecloth with a twisting motion to press out whey. Place your ‘something heavy’ over the bundle and allow to drain. Don’t over drain or this cheese will be TOO dry. I almost always over press – do some experimenting.

Yum! This cheese makes a lovely appetizer and fries well for some extra fun. Don’t be intimidated by cheesemaking – try it out! Have fun with it!

Have you made cheese before? Were you nervous your “first time?”

102 Comments

Filed under Cooking, Easy

102 Responses to Farmer’s Cheese – Easiest Homemade Cheese Recipe

  1. Hmmmm…I’ve been thinking of trying to make cheese for some time now. I think this recipe looks like something I might be able to handle – I make yogourt anyway, so maybe this whole process isn’t as tricky as I always have thought. I’m going to give this a go! :)
    Sheryl @ Flowery Prose recently posted…Northern cherry blossoms.

  2. Jackie

    I am so anxious to try this! Thank you for the recipe

  3. Carol

    Can you use milk that is turning sour?

    • Yes…. but it will taste a bit sour 😉

    • Tina M Comroe

      yes, and if you want it less sour add 1 cup of honey as you heat it up. I like making cheese this way, using the vinegar means you can avoid using the Rennet from animals..although the vegetable rennet does okay, I prefer vinegar.

      • Linda

        Does the vinager leave the vinager taste in the cheese? And what type vinager is best to use? I also didn’t know you could use pasturized milk? .

        • Ellen Cameron

          No, it won’t taste like vinegar. However, I would recommend using either ordinary distilled vinegar or white-wine vinegar (or lemon juice!) rather than red-wine vinegar, as red will turn it a rather un-appetizing color. If you make your cheese too dry, add honey and rosewater to it. This is an old –*old,* as in late-medieval — Catalonian recipe called “angel’s breath,” and it tastes fabulous on slices of apple or pear, or on toasted English muffins.

          • Sharon Jackson

            WOW. That is a wonderful tip! Thank you.

          • Sharon Jackson

            Ellen, this is fascinating. Is there a link where I can learn about this recipe? i.e. How much honey? How much rosewater?

          • Rosalie

            I’m a little confused – recipe says to separate the whey from the curds but then it says to add the whey & the curds to the collander??

          • hi, Rosalie – sorry this is confusing. What i meant is that you add the vinegar and the curds and whey WILL separate. The milk separates, becoming curds and whey. Once this first separation is complete, you pour the curds/whey together into a cheese cloth lined colander, which keeps the curds in the cloth and allows the whey to pass through, thus separating them. Make sense ? :)

    • Terri

      Carol,

      Yes you can! I make Aged Cheddar with a press; ricotta cheese and Parmesan. However, I accidently made Farmers cheese when I was evaporating some milk that I noticed was JUST STARTING to turn sour–meaning it was STILL drinkable. This is the BEST TIME to turn it into Farmers cheese as the milk is starting to produce lactic acid. It is then that you really don’t need to add lemon juice nor vinegar, and it turns out a very nice clean cheese. I have tried adding vinegar before, and it turns out a little sour for my taste. I made Farmers cheese just last night out of milk that was starting to sour. However, there is a stopping point to how sour the milk should be. Just remember–if it is “starting” to turn sour, it is perfect if you can still drink it. Then, you can still EAT it. :)

  4. Vindhya

    san herbs…it is called Paneer in India. You can cut them in cubes and fry them and cook with other vegetables and spices…yum…

  5. Vicki

    You can always use the farmers cheese mix with cream cheese , egg, sugar to taste,vanilla
    and use it for a filler in crepes–wrap as envelope put into a grease baking 8×8 pan, and top with some butter,bake for 30 minutes at 350 covered.Not a diet recipe.

    • Helena B.

      On the farm we had LOTS of natural milk; mom made this all the time; dad built a press for her and she made blintzes with the filling you described. Have never found farmer’s cheese in the US grocery stores so it was fantastic to find this recipe. Dzekuje.

  6. Pingback: Farmer's Cheese - Easiest Homemade Cheese Recipe — Self Sufficiency Magazine

  7. Rachel Wright

    Hi thanks for the recipe and maybe this is a dumb question. There are no times on this recipe, how long should each step take?

    • It’s kind of a ‘feel’ sort of thing. When you add the vinegar the milk separates almost immediately. The pressing part is more a matter of how much liquid you want out. The more you press out, the dryer the cheese (better for frying, not as good for just eating)… so i can’t really give you set times. I don’t even know how long it takes for water to boil 😉
      I hope that helps.
      Miranda & Pocket recently posted…Homestead Update: July 1 2014

      • shag

        I have dairy allergies. Could you do the same thing with coconut milk?
        I could use a vegetable rennet. I would prefer not to though. Maybe vinegar would work?

    • Vicki

      Basic Desert Crepe: 4eggs,1 cup of flour,1/2 c. of water, 1/2 c.of milk, 1/2 tsp. salt, 2 Tbsp melted butter, 2 tsp.sugar, 1 tsp. vanilla–I beat my egg and flour till it’s smooth,then whisk the milk,water slowly until incorporates, then add the rest of the ingredients.Use a small fry pan 9″ pile them up on a plate.Cover with damp paper towel so they don’t dry out.
      This is a single recipe.I double mine.
      Filling: 8 oz cream cheese, 1 lb. of farmers cheese,1 egg,1 tsp vanilla,sugar to taste,1/2 tsp salt.Mix in processor till smooth. Take about 1 tbsp a dollop on a crepe-roll in and tuck sides in put in a greased baking dish–after all are the dish,put slices of butter on top, Bake covered for 30 minutes at 350. Then serve up with thawed raspberries or whipping cream,ice cream. leftovers just heat up in a microwave for 1 min. Enjoy!

  8. Jan

    Out of one gallon of whole milk, approximately how much will this make? And before you start squeezing out the whey, do you let it cool down first or go right after the stove, while it’s hot?

    • Hmmm. let me know. (Note, i wrote this post a WHILE ago and haven’t made cheese in quite some time so i’m a bit rusty with my answers). How much will it make? Not much – a handful. I usually poured in the vinegar, let it separate, then pour it through a cheese cloth… usually once it’s cooled some. it’ll separate and won’t separate any further so i do it then. But i’m not afraid of burnign my fingers now and again 😉

  9. KaiSpiral

    I just made this! It was my first time making a cheese, and a lot of fun. I way over did the spices though. A head of garlic and a whole table spoon each of salt, red pepper, and rosemary is far to much for my taste. I used most of it mixed in with scrambled eggs, which was delicious. I’ll be making another batch tonight, half seasoned and half plain (for toast and such). Thank you so much for the recipe.

    I am curious though, can you drink the whey?

    • Yes, of course! You can drink the whey, feed it to chickens or pigs, use it as a garden spray for certain pests and funguses, make biscuits with it – you name it!
      Miranda & Pocket recently posted…Fiber Friday: Bernard the Pembroke Welsh Corgi in Felt!

      • Mary

        Just a warning to everyone about raw garlic. If you’re going to mix it with ANYTHING, be sure you use up the mixture within a couple of days because of the risk of botulism.

        This caution applies to most root vegetables, since botulinum bacteria lives in the ground.

        The cheese looks yummy and I’m going to have to try it – especially for my cheese-loving granddaughter.

        • joe

          seriously? there is a VERY SLIM chance of that……

          • Sharon Jackson

            I was also warned not to use raw garlic because of the naturally occurring bacteria in garlic. The advice was to use dried garlic and I imagine pickled garlic would be fine.

        • Sara

          Yeah… unless your going to can this and hermetically seal it – there should be no risk of botulism.

          The bacteria that creates the botulism toxin can only do so in the absence of oxygen. It is an obligate anaerobe. That’s why the primary way that people get botulism is by home canning something and either not reaching a high enough temperature to kill the bacteria or not having the appropriate PH to negate having to crank up the temperature high enough to kill the bacteria. Botulism is caused when clostridium botulinium bacterium (which IS everywhere) are in an environment with NO oxygen (which isn’t happening in your kitchen unless you are canning.) If this wasn’t the case then… well… we’d all have botulism.

    • Vonnie

      When I have leftover whey from making homemade ricotta (which is pretty close to this) I use it in things like rice and bread or anything in which I might use milk or broth, but that the slight acidic taste won’t affect much.

    • Sharon Jackson

      I also use it for soup base or stew base.

  10. Bookmarking this. Thank you so much!
    Prolific Recipes recently posted…7 Deadly Sins Of Cooking That You Should Avoid

  11. Pingback: Farmers Cheese - The Easiest Homemade Cheese Recipe — Homestead and Survival

  12. carla

    Do you taste the vinegar, or is it a “sweet ” cheese.

    • sweet or bland… i don’t taste the acv usually.

    • Shari

      With the vinegar it’s not sweet but you don’t taste it. I actually prefer using lemon juice. It doesn’t separate as quickly and I have to spoon off the curds then add more juice and spoon more off again but it makes a creamier farmer cheese and about 2 balls of cheese. However, the last time I made it, it did have a lemon flavor in both the cheese and the whey (I used 2 large lemons) – though I really liked how it turned out! And since I like to use the whey in fruit smoothies for breakfast, it works!

      • Carol

        I have seen this recipe using both fresh lemon juice and white vinegar. But I haven’t seen replies that say you can skim off the curds and add more lemon juice. That is very appealing to me bc I tried it with wv and only got about 1/2 to 1/3 c of cheese. Maybe I’ll be able to “squeeze” out a little more by adding more wv. Also, it wasn’t salty enough for me in my recipe by adding only a pinch of salt – this cheese definitely needs more salt. Thanks for this recipe. P.S. I’m Polish and we had Farmer’s cheese quite often.

  13. Louise

    Does T in this case mean teaspoon or tablespoon?? Thanks.

  14. Can you use buttermilk for a creamier thicker cheese?

  15. *dumb question* Once we add the ACV to the boiled milk, do we stir?

  16. Pingback: Farmer’s Cheese – Easiest Homemade Cheese Recipe - Lil Moo Creations

  17. Jessica

    Cant wait to try this! What can you do with they whey though?

  18. Sara

    This is awesome. I’ve been trying to figure out what to do with my milk since my son and I just don’t go through it fast enough. I want to make yogurt and kefir… but since those require starter cultures that I don’t have on hand… and I already have kombucha and fermented veggies bubbling away in the kitchen… I’m psyched to have mother option :)

    • You don’t need a starter culture for yogurt, Sara – you can just use some yogurt :) I make yogurt all the time and just use Nancy’s yogurt (any store bought yogurt that has real live cultures in it) I think i have a ‘make yogurt’ post on this blog somewhere 😉

  19. Age

    I made this just this morning with sundried tomatoes and oregano. I’ve been debating making my own cheese for ages, ever since a friend who owns a bakery posted a mozzerella tutorial. This recipe was simple enough to get me over my hesitation and i just tasted the still warm cheese and it’s lovely!

    Thanks for sharing a wonderfully simple recipe!

  20. Liz

    I just tried this with two week old raw milk (it hadn’t started to separate yet, but I wouldn’t really have wanted to drink it. The flavor is actually really good. I did get it way too dry, which I’ll be more careful about next time. It’s a great way to deal with milk that’s gotten old enough that some people around here won’t drink it, but that isn’t really at the sour milk stage.

  21. Rob

    Instead of weighting it, has anyone tried balling the cheese and hanging it the way Provolone is done???

  22. Libby

    I love making this cheese, but I use yogurt to do it, as I frequently buy cases of whole milk organic yogurt from a discount foods place. It’s great with garlic and herbs mixed in before the cooking, to it becomes seasoned throughout. Can be made with the fruit or vanilla yogurts, too, for a great bagel spread. Cheesecakes are easy with this one, just leave overnight and press well so it’s drier.

  23. I have made several kinds of cheese, most of them are all day projects that need to sit for a time. Making cheese that is quick, easy, and ready to eat is loads of fun!

  24. Melody

    This is excellent with raw goat milk. I get a little over a pound of cheese from a gallon of raw milk. you can also use the whey to replace part or all of the liquid in a bread recipe it works very well in my bread maker, adds protein and gives a good flavor.

  25. I just found your site today and really enjoy it! Great recipes I can’t wait to try. This farmers cheese will be the first! I also have a food blog but I cook mainly with venison. I also like your elk recipe and may give that a try when I get back out west. :)

  26. Delicious…but don’t try using it heavy cream, though. It just doesn’t fly. Learn from my failure! http://pixiespocket.com/2012/06/cheese-making-attempt-1-failure-into-soup.html
    Amber Pixie (@PixiesPocket) recently posted…Book Review: The Nourished Kitchen by Jennifer McGruther

  27. Ann

    I USED to live overseas and when I couldn’t find ricotta or cottage chess which was often, w would use this method with powdered whole milk reconstituted. It made really wonderful lasagna.

  28. Kitty K.

    What kind of cheese would this be like??? Cream cheese / mozzarella….

  29. kelli

    Can u use white vinegar?

  30. Danielle

    I’ve made a recipe similar to this except I used lemon juice instead of vinegar. Instead of pressing the cheese I just hang the cheese cloth around my cupboard knob with a bowl under to catch the whey. That way you never have to worry about it being to dry. Simply and easy. I usually do it at night so in the morning it’s ready. Yummy.

  31. Bobbie

    Made this last night with the family. Easy. Added 1T dried dill. The texture wasn’t ideal, but tonight we will have some lasagna with it.

  32. Leah

    Dumb question- at what point do you add veggies/spices? I feel lost after the draining part…..

  33. Jody K Nall

    Made this with my daycare kiddies and they LOVE IT!! Thank you for sharing this wonderful and easy recipe!!

  34. Sandy

    Is it possible to use canned evaporated milk for this by adding water to bring it to regular milk?

  35. Chris

    I have made cheese similar to this from time to time. I use the whey from this or from kefir insted of buttermilk when making soda bread.

  36. Cindy

    I Made This Cheese After Work Tonight.Added A Tbsp Of Tastefully Simple Dried Tomato Garlic Pesto Mix WhilE Boiling The MilK.Tasted Great.

  37. Jan

    Man this is so easy. The only hard part is not letting the milk scorch. The milk took a long time to come to a rolling boil….. then I new it was scorching….
    What did you do to prevent that? Stirring slows down the cooking more doesn’t it?

    • I heat the milk with a lid on – which helps it heat up more quickly. Otherwise, lots of stirring. I usually scorch a little, too – and make my husband clean it up. ha!

    • Ken

      use two pots, put water in the first one so the second one floats. The water will boil and heat the 2nd more evenly and reduce scorching. Will still have to stir some but not as constant.

  38. Pingback: Make Your Own Cheese | Be More Self Sufficient

  39. Laura Wickett

    For a quick, meatless dish we love to saute onions in butter, add in a package of egg noodles or pasta and crumble in the farmers cheese. Season with salt and pepper. Simple, quick and delicious! This one dates back to my grandmother and now my kids love it. I must try it with homemade farms cheese!!

  40. Nancy Barry

    Farmers cheese remids me of my Polish Babcia(grandma). I love it. Do you know if this recipe would work with soy milk, we have some dairy sensitivities in the family. I’d love to find a way to do cheese pierogi for them.

  41. Michelle

    Has anyone made this into a sweet cheese by adding honey or brown sugar? I make all my own bread and sometimes like just a little sweet instead of butter.

  42. Laura

    So how about how long does the something heavy sit on the wrapped up curds? Just until it’s firm? Then refrigerate?

  43. Cortney

    I’m sorry I’m just a bit confused it says seperate the way from the curds then it says to put both through the collander? But why did I seperate them then put them both into it together? Sorry never made cheese so this confuses me a little.

  44. sashay73

    Just made this cheese with half gallon of whole, store bought milk. I added fresh basic, chopped garlic, and chives from my newly awakening garden. Can’t wait to try it and spread it on celery for my 6 year old!!! Looks like I’ll have a cheese ball size hunk of fresh made cheese.

  45. For Cortney, a bit later than useful, maybe…the way I would do it would be to lay my cheesecloth over my colander(actually I dispense with the colander and just lay the cheesecloth over my bowl) and pour the kettle-full of now-separated curds and whey into the bowl. Then I lift the corners of the cheesecloth, bring them together (a big rubber band works great) and hang the resulting ‘bag’ on a chopstick or wooden spoon inserted into two neighboring handles on my cupboards (no knobs to use), so the whey drips into the bowl, sometimes as long as overnight (I go to bed late!).

  46. TJ Russell-Zapata

    Looks easy peasy. Gonna make some tomorrow.

  47. Norma Montenegro

    I remember my mom making chest at home when I was a little girl. I’m going to try this, it seems easy enough.

  48. Charlotte McDonald

    This is great. Thanks for the recipe. I do have a question and also a tip. My question is, does the milk really need to boil? Do we need this step to change the proteins in the milk? If not, it would be healthier to use raw milk that has not had it’s enzymes and amino acids destroyed.
    My tip is this: the whey from this cheese in not viable for lacto-fermentation projects. While your food will still ferment, the whey will not be the reason. Whey that has been heated above 118 degrees is a dead product. Always use whey from raw milk that has not been pasteurized for lacto-fermentation.

  49. About how long do you let drain. You didn’t give an estimated time.

    • Hi, Vicky – the length of time is totally up to you. The longer you drain/more your press the drier/harder the cheese. You want it drained enough to hold together and not be sopping wet, but as i mentioned in the post, if you drain/press to long/much it will be unpleasantly dry, though probably great for frying.
      Miranda & Pocket recently posted…Custom Nubbins: Maslow and Valerie

  50. Holly

    Can almond milk be used?

  51. Leanne

    Can you freeze this cheese once it is completed? How long of a fridge life does it have?

    • Yes, you can freeze it – fridge life will depend on how dry you make it, the dryer the longer it will last. But it makes a fairly small amount so we usually eat it up in a few days.

  52. Jessica

    It just says T salt and herbs. How many T of each?

    • Ultimately: totally to taste. Enough salt to taste salty and act as a preservative, at least a T. Enough herbs to taste as herby as you’d like – more or less than a T

  53. Hi there mates, how is everything, and what you
    desire to say about this piece of writing, in my view its truly awesome in favor
    of me.
    เบอร์มงคล recently posted…เบอร์มงคล

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge